Hobie Forums http://www.hobie.com/forums/ |
|
2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water http://www.hobie.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=30997 |
Page 1 of 2 |
Author: | Roadrunner [ Fri Sep 03, 2010 10:11 pm ] |
Post subject: | 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Note: This is the second in a two part series. Here's the link to part I: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=30980 Just when you think you have the perfect boat (and right after you get it all customized), Hobie comes along with the next edition. If you think the former Oasis is versatile, wait till you see what the 2011 version can do! General characteristics: The new hull has a finer bow, broader stern and less rocker. consequently it runs quieter, drier and with less pounding. Speed is in the same ballpark, with the 2011 Oasis appearing to be a tad faster (I'll have better information soon). Handling and rudder control are responsive and very similar to previous models. Longer cockpits are a welcome addition. Dual rudder controls are huge, allowing either partner to operate the boat without having to switch seats. The solo versatility is also very cool. Side mounted cockpit handles are well positioned and comfortable to grip. Here are some side by side pics of the two boats running together. The '10 pictured here pushes much more water with the bow (both boats are sitting about equally in the water here): Looking at the stern profiles, the lower rudder mount on the '10 is not as clean but the broader '11 pulls more stern wake: Stability: This boat was built for stability. Whether Hobie intended this or not, the flat decks open up some new possibilities: While I'm not suggesting that anyone stand up in their kayak, the Pro Angler might see some competition here! Need a little more stability for unseen wakes or mischievous partners? A broom handle inserted in the sail mast hole makes a great steady stick. (I'm sure Hobie doesn't endorse this one!) Caution: If attempting to stand solo, make sure you're leashed to the boat. If you fall overboard, even light winds will carry it away quickly! Tandem pedaling: This front passenger is getting her first Hobie ride -- her grin says it all! The boat accelerates well without much stern squat: Here's a profile view showing access to the rod holders from the rear cockpit: Solo pedaling: What happens when your partner doesn't feel like kayaking? Do you sit at home or find something else to do? Not necessary at all! The new Oasis has excellent solo manners from either cockpit -- the secret is in proper ballasting. Starting from the traditional rear seat, here is an unballasted profile: The bow is subject to windage, stability is slightly reduced (no big deal) and the shorter water line length limits speed. Ballasting with 55 lbs. in the bow regains a very credible profile and decent performance. Here's a cockpit view: Next, lets go to the front seat. Without ballast the nose is a little heavy and the rudder is somewhat on the high side, but not too bad! Adding 30 lb. in the cargo well balances the boat nicely. Here's the view from the boat: Some general comments about turning: The boat tends to pivot about the fins (when down). Soloing from the rear, steering is quick with the bow cutting in and stern swinging out mildly. From the front seat (again fins down), the stern swings wide, steering is not quite as quick. Tandem, the turn starts out slower; as momentum builds the turn accelerates. The boat spins quickest with rear fins down, front fins up. Fins-up turns are slower in all cases. Nevertheless, both Oases have a nice turn radius with the large rudder (standard since 2010). Sailing: If you're expecting a competitive sailer here, you'll be disappointed. Under sail power alone, the Oasis is probably best described as leisurely, with good stability for a sailing kayak and good rudder control. Add some easy pedaling to the sail and you can scoot around pretty well, in any direction, with or without wind. Criticisms: As skua said, this boat pretty much addressed the few shortcomings of the previous Oasis model. The only things that come to mind are 1) the front forward bungee screws sit in a drainage channel and appear to be unsealed through hull installations. I noticed when hosing off the boat this was a minor source of leakage into the hull. A little silicon should take care of it. 2) If paddling from the rear seat your hands might rub against the grips, depending on your stroke style. Summary: What can I say to sum this up except to warn you that this boat can be addictive! Too late for me though. With clean lines, efficiently used space, tons of features, loads of versatility, gobs of capacity and delightful manners, I've fallen under its spell. |
Author: | trainsktg [ Fri Sep 03, 2010 11:08 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
The only problem with me purchasing a new Oasis is that, for storage reasons, I'd have to sell the 2005 Outfitter to do it. Even then, with the new boat I'd still be limited to the speed that the kids can pedal in the 2010 Outfitter . Still, its worth considering, and both reviews will help my decision immensely. Thanks. Keith |
Author: | moses_pl [ Sat Sep 04, 2010 12:30 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
mhmm is this my first hobie mirage kayak = perhaps the first in Poland? ajajaj hard decision : 2011 TI (not "dune") vs. 2011 Oasis thx - great review Poland: 04.09.2010 14°C brrrr |
Author: | stringy [ Sat Sep 04, 2010 1:41 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Great stuff. Thanks again Roadrunner. Love the steady stick.... and the disclaimer! So....which boat are you entering in next years Bay 2 Bay race? |
Author: | KayakingBob [ Sat Sep 04, 2010 12:14 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Another great Roadrunner post. I have no interest in the Oasis, and it still was a great read! |
Author: | stringy [ Sun Sep 05, 2010 5:52 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Hmmm... Your performance update is interesting Roadrunner -thanks. I thought it may have gone a little faster. I'm guessing though the relatively short waterline length doesn't help, especially compared to racing skis. Looks like you've got it up on a plane in a couple of those pics! Surprisingly, maybe the heaviest person needs to be in the front? |
Author: | Roadrunner [ Sun Sep 05, 2010 10:58 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Stringy, I agree we should try it with the heavier person in the front. The area where we were doing sprints (relatively flat water) had no shoreline where we could get out and shift positions so we didn't try it that way. I personally prefer to see speed and efficiency in a hull, but Hobie's top priorities appear to be stability and capacity with the new Oasis. I was concerned that the boat might be a little slower than past models as a result. So it was great news that the engineers managed to keep the performance on par with the older models. I like the "one hour fast cruise" as the best indicator of performance. Basically this is how far one can travel in exactly one hour (all measured with the GPS). This is run in two directions along the same track so any bias induced one way should be mostly canceled in the opposite direction. Even so, wind and chop always induce some loss in speed. Sprints are interesting but don't have much practical value IMO. Still, they open a window to the potential success for performance options. BTW, a well tuned factory Drive with Turbofins is always the benchmark Drive. Previous one hour solo runs with the Oasis II (2009/10 model) were 4.87 and 4.88 MPH in calm to LV conditions, so getting 4.88 out of this new hull in slightly heavier weather was better than expected. Likewise, solo sprint speeds for the Oasis I are 6.4MPH; Oasis II 6.3 and new Oasis 6.5 -- no complaints there. Tandem performance is really hard to gauge. My fastest one hour time with my daughter (B2B race partner) was 5.27MPH with our '08 Oasis. My current partner and I just completed 5.42 with the new Oasis. I'm reluctant to call this faster due to the different circumstances, but I feel comfortable calling it comparable. Tandem sprints? You're right, that picture looks like the hull is planing -- not sure what to think of it. Finally, given that both boats have the same length and width, possibilities are limited. I feel this new Oasis gives up a little in lower speed efficiency due to its higher skin friction, but gets it back at the higher cruise speeds with less rocker and better hydrodynamic lift so I can't really complain. New users should be happy with its generous stability, "plus size" users should be happy with its ability to carry almost anybody that can climb into a kayak, so there is good news for everybody! As mentioned, I'm very anxious to try a front seat one-hour solo this week, and hope the weather is suitable for a fair run -- always optimistic for a little more speed! |
Author: | husky13 [ Mon Sep 06, 2010 6:28 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Roadrunner, nice review as always! You can say something more about sailing, I did not understand the differences with 2010. thanks H13 |
Author: | skua [ Tue Sep 07, 2010 2:16 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Roadrunner, thanks for the review and all the additional information. Although the old Oasis (2008 and before) seems to be a little faster solo, the new one seems to be as least as fast as the older ones when used tandem. Could this be because the new front cockpit allows longer adults to push the pedals better? I always find the front cockpit in my 2008 Oasis too cramped to effectively power the pedals. Although the bigger stability may cost a little in terms of speed, the possibilities to stand and for (outrigger-less) sailing are really nice. It makes a very versatile family boat. As stringy said, that stick in the mast receiver is a great idea! |
Author: | husky13 [ Tue Sep 07, 2010 2:49 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
..the new cup holder seems to be smaller |
Author: | rkim01 [ Tue Sep 07, 2010 5:17 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Are there no rod holders for front person? |
Author: | Thierry [ Wed Sep 08, 2010 1:19 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: 2011 Oasis Part Two: On the Water |
Hello Roadrunner, this is an excellent review. Just a little question, is it possible to store the cart upside down in the scupper holes behind the back seat? Thierry |
Page 1 of 2 | All times are UTC - 8 hours [ DST ] |
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |