tonystott wrote:
I also hear what you say about a multi-capable boat not being very good in any of its disciplines, but I am not so sure when talking about Islands, as they are pretty good as stand-alone kayaks, pedal well, sail pretty well for a una rig (and now we have a downwind sail to play with as well), and they make a pretty good platform for socialising, expeditions and even scuba diving. Not all of us feel the need to add motors to enjoy our craft, although I entirely understand when people do.
The difference between very good and pretty good is subjective and depends on experience. I agree that the TI is a pretty good boat that does pretty good with pedaling and sailing...but a very good sailing boat like my Getaway is a world of different creature if you love sailing (of course the excellent sailing I got out of my Corsair 24 was even better). I enjoy my "pretty good" sailing/paddling Triak, but the Getaway is my "go to" when I want a sailing thrill. And it isn't only boatspeed that makes the difference between, pretty good, very good and excellent...it's the wetness of ride, plushness of accommodations, ease of handling...yadda yadda. Someone once wrote that you can have any two of three things in a sailboat, speed; comfort; and low cost. My Getaway has two (low cost and good speed); my triak only has one (low cost--although it is pretty comfortable for a kayak).