mmiller wrote:
Still, the endurance factor over time usually goes to the Mirage.
Ok, I'm about to do the unthinkable. I have
tremendous respect for Matt Miller, and at the risk of forfeiting any warranty claim in the future, I have to question (or disagree?) with just one sentence. I'm not sure that "the endurance factor over time usually goes to the Mirage."
Matt's dead right about the torque, and if you're going on a long tour with fully loaded traditional kayakers, you'll notice that if you split the gear evenly, the traditional kayaker will have more of his top speed limited then the mirage drive boater. The torque makes taking on extra weight, much less of an issue.
The endurance factor that Matt talks about is probably less correct in practical use for the following reason: Mirage drive boats, by design force the user to have short "strides", while a sea kayak can use nice LONG strokes to achieve the same speed. The short strides of a Mirage kayak can be compared to walking, while the long strokes of a paddle kayak can be compared to a joggers lengthened stride.
Going fast in a mirage kayak feels like speed walking, you're always limited by your short stride. Going fast in a traditional kayak is different because you gain the benefit of a longer stroke at a slower cadence. Where the analogy falls apart is in the fact that the longer stroke of kayaking isn't as tiring as jogging, its more like changing to a higher gear on a bicycle. If you were on a bike and told to go fast, you'd work your way up to a gear that allowed you to slow your cadence but cover more distance. In addition to all of the hull design benefits of a traditional kayak, it's that longer stroke which can give a benefit over a long trip.
At the end of the day, if you're
only buying your mirage drive kayak for speed, you should look elsewhere. But, if like most users, speed is simply a factor in a decision that involves juggling several balls, then the Mirage Drive can't be beat.
A Hobie Mirage Drive kayak is like the Mercedes-Benz of kayaks. It's not a Lamborghini, but that's what makes it so easy to live with on a daily basis.
If you want speed, buy the Adventure, it's faster then any recreational kayak that I've tried, and doesn't give up much to the sleekest of traditional kayaks. It also gives you almost all of the benefits of the rest of the Hobie kayak line.
--- Hey Matt, we're still cool right?
---